The Metropolis as a Defiant Area Towards Hindutva Politics

As I bought off the bus from Hyderabad to Pune and bought into an autorickshaw, I noticed a march the place individuals have been holding torches and saffron flags. After making certain that the rickshaw driver was not a Hindu, I requested, “What is that this about?”

“It’s some Hindutva march. It is extremely frequent within the metropolis,” the driving force responded, seemingly after doing his personal security verify.

“I’m not from right here. In actual fact, I’m from Pratapgarh, Uttar Pradesh. I’m a graduate and have been driving round a buddy’s autorickshaw from the time I got here right here right here,” he continued because the auto crossed hoardings of ‘Hindustan for Hindus’.

“I’m additionally from a political Muslim household and I don’t just like the politics unfolding in Uttar Pradesh and that’s why I bought out. It’s fairly loopy today,” he mentioned.

“You could have heard of this movie, The Kashmir Information,” he continued. “Kaun padha likha movie ko itihaas samajhta hai? Sab itihiaas badalne me lage hue hai (Which educated individual thinks of a movie as historical past? Everyone seems to be busy altering historical past.)”

He requested me the place I’m from.

“I’m from Hyderabad,” I replied.

Achha shehar hai (It’s a good metropolis). Hyderabad is just not like this. My brother has gone there. I heard that it’s not loopy like right here,” he mentioned.


In January 2020, as I waited for Bhim Military chief Chandra Shekhar Aazad to come back and tackle a crowd at Crystal Gardens in Hyderabad’s Mehdipatnam, a woman in her mid-50s, carrying a hijab, was explaining to different ladies round her that the promise of Telangana was that of energy to Dalits and Bahujans. 

In the identical month, I met a 19-year-old Muslim medical scholar who had turned up alone for the Million March towards the Citizenship Modification Act (CAA) and Nationwide Register of Residents (NRC) in Hyderabad.

“My associates didn’t flip up however I believed I ought to be right here,” she mentioned. “We are going to stick collectively in the course of the march.”

Protestors wave Indian Tri-colours throughout an illustration towards the amended Citizenship Act, NRC and NPR at Indira Park in Hyderabad, Saturday, January 4, 2020. Picture: PTI.

Collectively, we walked the NTR Floor at RTC crossroads. It was an train in political schooling and changing into a citizen, which we undertook collectively. 


In an tackle on the Deccan Historic Congress, held in April 1945 below the patronage of the final Nizam of Hyderabad, Mirn Osman Ali Khan, then vice-chancellor of the Osmania College, Nawab Ali Yawar Jung, spoke in regards to the distinction of the Deccan in standing defiantly towards the singular imposition from the North. He mentioned that the resistance of the South to pressures from the North had baffled efforts to determine singular rule in India.


In 2018, when Uttar Pradesh chief minister Yogi Adityanath mentioned the Bharatiya Janata Celebration (BJP) would throw out All India Majlis-e-Ittehadul Muslimeen (AIMIM) chief Asaduddin Owaisi if the social gathering got here to energy in Telangana, identical to the Nizam of Hyderabad was thrown out, Owaisi took recourse to historic consciousness. He mentioned Adityanath didn’t know historical past; that the Nizam had by no means been thrown out, however was made the Raj Pramukh.

In one other speech within the Telangana Meeting, AIMIM MLA Akbaruddin Owaisi mentioned, “Jawaharlal Nehru had mentioned if there’s a actual idea of India which exists and which could be known as a ‘miniature India’, that’s the Hyderabad state of the Nizam. Is it not historical past? Nizam was the one one who had given cash for the interpretation of the Bhagavad Gita. Nizam gave cash for a number of temples.”


In November 2017, Urdu was declared the second official language of Telangana. The BJP interpreted this as a minority appeasement programme. Nonetheless, what this framing, associating faith with language, ignores is the lengthy historical past of Urdu within the state and in Hyderabad metropolis.

The area has fostered a number of languages and plenty of luminous Telugu writers spoke of Urdu as their very own language. Dasharadhi Rangacharya wrote in his autobiography, Jeevanayaanam, that faith can’t be ascribed to Urdu. He claimed Urdu as a lot his personal as Telugu. 

Telugu poet and author Kaloji Narayana Rao pointed to the complexity and intermingling of varied languages and linguistic cultures within the area in his autobiography, Naa Godava, writing:

“My mom spoke Kannada and Marathi. She learnt Telugu solely after coming to our home. My father didn’t know Marathi. His ancestors have been Maharashtrians, so he maybe understood, however couldn’t converse. He spoke Hindi. So there was no frequent language between my mom and father. Their marriage occurred in Tirupati. Folks from one aspect didn’t know Telugu; individuals from the opposite didn’t know Kannada and Marathi. I’m wondering how they married? My mom spoke in Marathi, my father in Urdu. They used to grasp one another. We spoke in Urdu to father, Marathi to mom and in Telugu to our friends. Teen batti, chaar rasta…” 

It should even be famous that Kaloji was a distinguished leftist and was towards feudalism. 

In July 2022, in response to a tweet by the Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) in Gujarati, taking a dig on the BJP, the latter tweeted in Urdu, assuming they have been returning the favour. What they overlook was that Urdu is the language of the land. 


In an Iftar occasion in L.B. Stadium in 2019, Telangana chief minister Ok. Chandrashekar Rao quoted Mahatma Gandhi to say, “These should not my phrases. They’re Mahatma Gandhi’s. That Telangana is a vital instance for the world of Ganga-Jamuni tehzeeb. Gandhiji mentioned others ought to be taught from this. That is our standing…” 

In December 2021, Telangana minister Ok.T. Rama Rao invited comedians Kunal Kamra and Munawar Faruqui to the state when their reveals have been cancelled in different cities. Hyderabad is “welcoming of all cultures and criticisms,” he had mentioned. 


On July 1 this 12 months, simply earlier than the nationwide govt assembly of the BJP was to be held in Hyderabad, fascinating hoardings started to appear within the metropolis. One referenced the favored Netflix collection Cash Heist, calling prime minister Modi a ‘robber of the nation’.

A poster focusing on Prime Minister Modi in Hyderabad impressed by Netflix collection ‘Cash Heist’. Picture: Twitter/ journopranav

The symbolism right here was fairly apt. Cash Heist is a couple of group of robbers who rob the nationwide financial institution to show the issues of the financial system and critique the federal government’s management over it. The present presents the robbers as conscience-keepers; as Robin Hoods of kinds. On this hoarding, they’re proven exposing the issues of the Union authorities.

Different hoarding got here up too, which learn, ‘Sufficient Modi’ and ‘Don’t kill individuals, Modi’ with the hashtag #ByeByeModi itemizing out a number of issues of the BJP authorities.


“Amidst the rising saffronisation of areas, I one way or the other discover Hyderabad a bit breathable. Maybe it’s my bias, for I’m from right here,” I mentioned to my educational associates 

“We aren’t from right here however we selected this metropolis. It truly is just like the New York of India,” one in all them mentioned in jest. 

“No actually! The town enables you to be,” one other added.


Chand Bibi, the warrior queen of the Deccan, fought towards Mughal annexation. Emperor Akbar couldn’t increase his kingdom due to this valiant lady. This queen regent, in some ways, represents the defiance of the Deccan towards the domination of the north, mentioned researcher Sarah Waheed, whereas speaking about her current work on Chand Bibi.


Two historians discussing modern politics spoke thus:

“They’re taking away our areas…saffronising them…”

“We can not quit… in such an onslaught, we should dare to think about alternatively.. They are going to try and steal our creativeness however we should resist and picture of collectiveness and solidarity.” 


These disparate occasions, unfold throughout time and geographical places, level to the symbolic significance of Hyderabad-Deccan as a territory in defiance of the majoritarian Hindutva politics of right now. The spirit of the Deccan is now spearheaded by Hyderabad metropolis.

It should be acknowledged that lots of the above incidents are undoubtedly politically motivated, and a few may even be two-faced. In actual fact, among the political forces which make claims for tolerance are themselves perpetrators of violence towards residents and activists. There are additionally many Hindu supremacist claims by the identical political figures.

Regardless of all this, it’s important to notice that Hyderabad lends itself to this various creativeness. That despite their very own fault traces, political forces are pressured to put declare to various, pluralistic politics, says one thing in regards to the place greater than these people and political events. Hyderabad stands distinct when in most different elements of India, majoritarianism is being peddled proudly, with none qualms. 

The ‘alternativeness’ of creativeness lies within the declare for plurality amidst the forceful Hinduisation of the society; the declare for historic consciousness amidst the widespread discrediting of historical past; of acceptance amidst widespread separation; of Muslim belongingness amidst othering.

It isn’t that Hyderabad is ideal; removed from it. It has its personal issues of ghettoisation and communal politics. However as somebody who belongs to the town, the town permits me to suppose that another creativeness is feasible. Maybe it’s a figment of my creativeness, however my competition is that locations lend themselves to sure sorts of creativeness; not all locations could be every thing. It’s due to the symbolic significance of the town that it’s attracting Muslim migration from different elements of the nation the place they’re persecuted.

It’s maybe due to this attribute that the RSS-BJP is making an attempt laborious to redefine Hyderabad by reinterpreting and weaponising historical past and actually occupying area via constructions, such because the Bhagyalakshmi temple, which encroaches on the historic Charminar; the RSS karyakarta rallies; public assembly; and, just lately, the massive BJP govt meet.

BJP Telangana unit president Bandi Sanjay with Prime Minister Narendra Modi throughout BJP nationwide govt assembly held on July 4 in Hyderabad. Picture: Twitter.

Hyderabad has been thought-about a problem for the Hindutva creativeness, proper from the early twentieth century. Because the Thirties, the Hindu Mahasabha and Arya Samaj have been working to assemble Mir Osman Ali Khan as an oppressive ruler ruling over the bulk Hindu inhabitants. This framing of the historical past of Hyderabad as communal and oppressive in direction of Hindus continues so far. Proof of this may be seen in Adityanath’s claims to rid Hyderabad of ‘Nizam tradition’, or the fixed framing of the annexation of Hyderabad state into India as ‘liberation’. 

The Hyderabad of my creativeness, traced from the anecdotes above, is placing up a valiant struggle towards the Hindutva onslaught. As Hyderabadis, we’re standing towards the colonisation of our creativeness. It’s these fertile, pluralistic, multifarious imaginations that India wants right now.

In actual fact, most areas possess these imaginations however sadly, they’re drowned out by the singular narrative of the nation and Hindutva. It’s the distinction of Hyderabad that it’s nonetheless in a position to undertaking small voices of plurality, difficult the Hindutva hegemony. It’s this spirit that must be nurtured and multiplied throughout India with the intention to struggle towards the Hindutva forces. 

C. Yamini Krishna works on movie historical past, city historical past and Deccan historical past. She is part of the Khidki collective. She presently teaches at FLAME College. 

Featured picture: College students maintain placards as they elevate slogans throughout a protest towards Citizenship Modification Act (CAA) and Nationwide Register of Residents (NRC) at Maulana Azad Nationwide Urdu College in Hyderabad, Tuesday, Dec. 17, 2019. Picture: PTI.

This text was first printed on The Wire.

Supply hyperlink

Previous post Asus’ most costly gaming telephone, Microsoft Floor Laptop computer Go 2 launched, new OnePlus sensible TV and different high tech information of the week
Next post IT Bonalu celebrated at T- Hub 2.0